"So um, you were in that show Heroes', yeah?” he asked Panettiere -- who then unbelievably asked him out for a drink after the show.
"I don't have my phone on me," he said.
A little too smooth... and the young man is an actor, as it turns out.
But after the show, Monahan said the whole thing was legit... at least, that's what he said at first.
Click "next" to see -- and learn -- more.