David Blaine, the "street magic" artist known for his feats of endurance, recently tried to show Manning a card trick as he taped a new special for TLC -- but it turned out the trick wasn't in the cards.
As the trick unfolded, not only did Blaine know which cards Manning had picked -- but he also managed to steal the quarterback's watch, according to the Huffington Post.
Manning made an estimated $26.5 million in salary and endorsements last year... so he can afford a new watch.
Another Vince Lombardi Trophy, on the other hand, would be priceless.
For more on Blaine's most famous feats, check out my gallery: Magic & Endurance: David Blaine's Greatest Stunts.